← Back to Execution Reports
Print to PDF: browser Print (Ctrl+P / Cmd+P)
Select Quarter:
2026Q22026Q1
Preview Report: 2026Q2 Routing × 2026Q3 Benchmarks

Preview, not a Rule 5310 review quarter. Routing and PFOF come from 2026Q2 (606, latest month in that quarter); execution quality comes from 2026Q3 amended 605 benchmarks. Route shares from one period are applied to benchmarks from another.

Adopted Clearing Firm Rule 606 Reports

Under FINRA Rule 6151, this broker-dealer adopts by reference the 606 routing reports of its clearing firm(s): HILLTOP SECURITIES INC.. Under FINRA Rule 5310.09(c), introducing broker-dealers must independently examine execution quality and compare clearing firm routing against competing market centers.

⚠️ 49 Competing-Market Differences Flagged Across 144 Buckets Requiring Rule 5310.09 Disposition
CRD #14627 Review Period: 2026Q2 Filing: Adopts clearing firm report

FIRST SECURITIES NORTHWEST, INC. (CRD #14627) — SEC Rule 606 Order Routing & FINRA Rule 5310.09 Execution Quality Report

Mix-Adjusted Grade: F
Flagged Disparities by Category:
Other Equities × Market: 2 flagged Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit: 22 flagged S&P 500 Proxy × Market: 2 flagged S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit: 23 flagged

Executive Best Execution & Order Routing Analysis

FIRST SECURITIES NORTHWEST, INC. (CRD #14627) operates as an introducing broker-dealer adopting the SEC Rule 606 order routing disclosures of HILLTOP SECURITIES INC.. Under FINRA Rule 5310.09(c), introducing firms that rely on clearing firm routing arrangements remain obligated to independently examine execution quality and compare results against competing market centers. In 2026Q2, non-directed customer order flow was routed primarily to Virtu Americas, LLC (27.7%), Global Execution Brokers LP (26.1%), CITADEL SECURITIES LLC (21.8%).

During 2026Q2, the firm reported $104,626.35 in total net payment for order flow (PFOF) and execution rebates received across its order routing arrangements. Disclosed net payment rates for market orders averaged 12.59 ¢ and marketable limit orders averaged 12.30 ¢. FINRA Rule 5310.09 requires rigorous surveillance of potential conflicts of interest when order routing decisions coincide with financial remuneration from execution venues.

Our mix-adjusted benchmark analysis flagged 49 material differences across the 144 Amended Rule 605 order size and security buckets where FIRST SECURITIES NORTHWEST, INC.'s routed execution trailed competing peer benchmarks by more than 1.0 basis points. Under FINRA Rule 5310.09, broker-dealers must conduct regular and rigorous committee reviews comparing execution quality achieved against competing market centers they do not route to. Each flagged competing-market difference requires documented supervisory disposition and committee review in the firm's permanent compliance records.

SEC Rule 606 Order Routing Summary

Disclosed non-directed customer order routing shares, total PFOF remuneration, and net rates by execution venue.

Execution VenueRoute %Disclosed PFOF (USD)Net Rate (¢/100 sh)
Virtu Americas, LLC (NITE)27.7%$7,331.014.28 ¢
Global Execution Brokers LP26.1%$15,721.2633.36 ¢
CITADEL SECURITIES LLC (CDRG)21.8%$38,344.0618.69 ¢
Wolverine Execution Services, LLC20.7%$12,397.8039.48 ¢
Matrix Executions, LLC / Simplex Trading, LLC19.9%$14,936.9536.07 ¢
StoneX Financial, Inc.19.8%$5,209.944.83 ¢
GTS SECURITIES LLC15.8%$5,029.805.00 ¢
G1 Execution Services, LLC (ETMM)11.2%$3,404.044.87 ¢
UBS Securities, LLC6.9%$2,251.494.90 ¢
Sample Unlocked Bucket

S&P 500 Proxy × Market • $1k–$5k (ROUND)

Full execution metrics for routed flow against the mix-adjusted peer benchmark and competing market centers. (164,769 covered orders in tier)

RoleMarket CenterRouting Share (606)PFOF Rate (¢/100)NPI (bps)Peer Bench (bps)Fill RateShortfall vs Bench
Routed VenueG1 Execution Services, LLC (ETMM)9.8%5.00 ¢1.9 bps2.0 bps100.0%-0.2 bps
Routed VenueVirtu Americas, LLC (NITE)27.9%5.00 ¢1.8 bps2.1 bps92.3%-0.3 bps
BenchmarkMix-Adjusted Peer Benchmark——2.0 bps2.0 bps93.1%—
Competing VenueCompeting venue A——3.5 bps2.0 bps——
Competing VenueCompeting venue B——1.8 bps2.0 bps——

Flagged Competing-Market Differences (49 Locked Buckets)

Scored execution buckets requiring committee evaluation and supervisory disposition under FINRA Rule 5310.09.

CategorySize TierRule 5310.09 Status & Competing Markets
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$250–$999 • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit<$250 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$250–$999 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$50k–$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$50k–$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit≥$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit≥$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit≥$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$250–$999 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$50k–$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$10k–$20k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$250–$999 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit<$250 • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit<$250 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$5k–$10k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$50k–$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit<$250 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$1k–$5k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × nonmarketable_limit$20k–$50k • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × nonmarketable_limit$250–$999 • ODD🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × Market$1k–$5k • FRACT🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × Market$1k–$5k • FRACT🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
Other Equities × Market≥$200k • ROUND🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification
S&P 500 Proxy × Market$250–$999 • FRACT🔒 Locked — Unlock Workspace to View Competing Venues & Record Committee Justification

Complete Your FINRA Rule 5310.09 Best Execution Review

Unlock all 144 order size and security tiers, reveal competing market center metrics, record supervisory dispositions, and export signed committee minutes.

Unlock Workspace → Request 7-day committee preview